Siblings

“He’s your brother.”

“She’s your sister.”

The image I have of a mother coaxing a son or daughter to treat someone more charitably because they are kin is surely drawn from TV or movies. While I have four sisters, I came along well after them, so I never experienced the interfilial warfare between siblings that is fodder for so many scenes in pop culture and literature. Nor did I have a brother; ever since Cain and Abel, there have been bitter fraternal feuds that I have only read about or watched with a bucket of popcorn nearby.

That appeal, though, to think of the person you’re mad at not as a nemesis but as a sibling, still resonates. Maybe you can picture your mom scolding you to treat your sibling more kindly than you think you should have to. Or maybe you can conjure the scene from cinema, literature or elsewhere, in which a beleaguered mom beseeches their child to do the same, not because the opponent is deserving of mercy, but because they are kin.

Honestly, that image may be the source of (most of) my approach to ethical life.

We have baked within us the tendency to think of “us” and “them”. Somehow, we never are in the wrong and they always are, regardless of the issue or the context or the facts. And as we confront the crimes they have perpetrated, whether they be truly heinous war crimes or crossing the invisible line in the backseat of the station wagon, there is a self-righteous comfort to treating them as the villain and us as the hero (or the victim, or sometimes both). We can put the “them” on blast without any mixed feelings.

It’s taking me a long time to realize this, and I’m still awfully imperfect at the realization, but when you pull the lens all the way back, to the distance in which all 8 billion of us are in the same frame, to the perspective of a creative parent who loves each one of us as if we were a hard-won only, the voice of God you hear is that worn-out mom:

He’s your brother. She’s your sister.

What the trope doesn’t include is the unspoken second line of that plea:

Love them like I do, anyway.

In a limited sense, Jesus says this in Matthew 18. (Given that he is talking about relations within a church community that doesn’t yet exist, you can join me in thinking that this is a projection back from some late-1st century or early-2nd century pastors who were just so tired of the passive-aggressive infighting of their congregations.) Whatever the provenance, Jesus tells his believers that, if someone has wronged them, the first move should not be to blow them up on the socials and get them canceled; it should be to go directly to them in private and talk it out with them. If that doesn’t work, then bring in a wing-person. And then escalate it only if that doesn’t work.

(As someone who managed teams for 30 years, it’s nice to know that my instinct when confronted by tattletales was the same as Jesus’ (or Matthew’s, anyway.))

That’s not because we’re called to be conflict-avoiders. It’s because we’re called to take the long view.

That person you’re really … ticked off at … right now? God wants you to spend eternity in heaven, with them. That person that is clearly on the wrong track? Yeah, them too.

And if you’re right, and they are really the ones who are wrong, you know what will get them back on track? Not you fussing at them. Not you getting them deplatformed.

No, what might eventually get them back is helping them remember that their family embraces everybody, everywhere, always. And, pissed off as you may be, righteously angry as you may be, God can use you as a messenger for that important lesson, while teaching it to you as well. Or you can give in to self-righteousness, which I think pushes both them and you a little farther from the gates of heaven.

This approach to human relations is horribly unsatisfying. It is so much … maybe not fun, but gleefully reinforcing … to be able to rail without consequences against someone without regard to your shared fraternity and sorority. This is one of those many things God calls us to that I wish weren’t so. Which is one way of knowing that it might be true.

God is always a mom coaxing us to remember the long game. We’re all siblings, and we’re all going to continue to be siblings. If we remembered that, we might have a little more peace, in the backseat of the station wagon and in the world at large.


Discover more from Reading Francis

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Leave a Reply